A court in Mumbai has convicted and sentenced a 31-year-old Worli man to six months imprisonment for ‘sexually harassing’ a 66-year-old woman by showing the middle finger and screaming “f**k yourself bloody b***h” to her and her son in a road rage incident at Hughes Road in 2018.
A magistrate’s court has said that through the crime, the woman’s fundamental right to live with dignity was attacked.
Allegations by Woman:
The woman told the court that on September 17, 2018, her son and she were going to their office by car. Around 11.40am, when they reached Cadbury Junction, a red car suddenly came from the left side and pushed them towards the divider. The woman said this continued for about 100m distance.
Thereafter, when they went on to Hughes Road, they noticed that a car was trying to overtake them. Moments later they stopped at the signal. The woman said that the red car stopped on their left side and the driver rolled down the window and showed them the middle finger.
The woman told her son to “maintain peace”, but the accused abused her. He then tried to drive away, but her son but her son blocked him with his car. Meanwhile, a traffic cop reached the spot and accused Aniket Patil was taken to Gamdevi police station.
Defence:
The defence claimed that though it was the woman’s son who abused Patil, he had used his influence as a lawyer to register a false FIR. Refuting this, the court said that an advocate can also be a victim of the crime.
Mumbai Court:
The court heard both sides and Girgaum metropolitan magistrate Nadeem A Patel said,
No lady of 66-years will put her character at stake to file false FIR on petty issues. It is also not a case acceptable to prudent man to use his mother to file false FIR of sexual harassment on road rage.
Adding further the court noted,
Every woman in a society has the right to live with dignity. In a crime which is related to the modesty of women, it is an attack on their fundamental rights to live with dignity.
The court refused to let the accused, Aniket Patil, off on a bond of good behaviour. The magistrate said that he was grown up enough to know the consequences of his actions. The court added,
In such a case, if unwarranted leniency is shown to the accused, it will send the wrong signal to society.
Court Refutes False Allegations
The magistrate said that any woman can be victim of molestation twice by two different persons.
Refuting the defence argument that the woman had previously filed a sexual harassment case against another accused, the court said,
Filing of one prior FIR related to lady is in a habit of filing such FIRs to extract the money. ..Any woman can be the victim of molestation twice. It is sad and unfortunate but true that she is the victim of molestation twice by two different persons.
The court was thus of the opinion that the accused should not be released on a good behaviour bond or on fine.
Patil was also fined Rs 1,000. The maximum sentence attracted in the case was one-year jail. Among the four witnesses cited by public prosecutor B U Gavali were the woman and her son.
In the 18-page judgment copy, the court also explained why showing the middle finger to a woman is a vulgar gesture that amounts to insulting her modesty — originally the symbol meant to threaten someone with sexual violence.
What do you think of this punishment? Justified OR Too Harsh? Will Women showing such gestures publicly also get similar conviction? Leave your comments below:
OUR PREVIOUS ARTICLE ON SIMILAR CASE FROM DELHI
Man Held Guilty For Showing Middle Finger To Woman | But Reverse Is Empowerment For Bollywood Feminists
ALSO READ –
Mumbai Woman Booked For Name Calling & Outraging Modesty Of Female Neighbour
#WTFeminism! Neha Dhupia On Roadies Justifies Girlfriend Having Five Boyfriends At A Time
Parineeti Chopra Promptly Abuses Son As “Criminal & AS****”; NCW Clarifies Daughter-in-Law Was Culprit
Accused Of Molestation, Man Reaches Delhi High Court Dressed As Woman
Twinkle Khanna Should “Tweak” Misogyny First At Home & Then Lecture Others On Feminism
ALSO WATCH –
Karnataka Health Minister Dr K Sudhakar Labelled Misogynist | Your Take?
Join our Facebook Group or follow us on social media by clicking on the icons below
Join our Facebook Group or follow us on social media by clicking on the icons below
If you find value in our work, you may choose to donate to Voice For Men Foundation via Milaap OR via UPI: voiceformenindia@hdfcbank (80G tax exemption applicable)
Follow Us
