In a rare case, the Karnataka High Court has reprimanded a woman and directed her to pay Rs 25,000 as a cost to her ex-husband since she abused the process of law by registering a false case under section 498A IPC to harass him.
Karnataka High Court
Case:
35-year-old Nazia Asma, a resident of Lashkar Mohalla, Mysore, was married to 50-year-old Faisal Ahmed Khan, a mechanical engineer who was working in Kuwait
The marriage took place on July 21, 2008 and a female child was born to them
Nazia did not agree to join her husband to go abroad and in order to save the marriage, the husband himself resigned from his job
Later in 2011, Nazia left home for her sister’s engagement ceremony, however, never returned
Her husband eventually got another job in Bahrain and left the country alone in 2012
In April 2012, Nazia filed a complaint against Khan and his family members at the Women’s Police Station at Mysore, alleging harassment and demand for dowry
She had alleged that Khan and his family had demanded Rs 3 lakh and additional money to purchase a car while filing a false case under 498A
The Mysuru police had filed charge-sheet only against Faisal for offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 506 of IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of Dowry Prohibition Act
Though the police filed a charge-sheet only against the husband, the High Court found no material against him
Observing that wife’s statements in the complaint were full of contradictions, the court noted that the woman had first alleged that Khan; a) tried to kill her by trying to hang her, and after some days had said that; b) he tried to kill her by making her fall from a motorcycle
The court also observed that the complainant was now silent on how she escaped, when her husband tried to hang her or why she sat behind him on the motorcycle even assuming that he had tried to hang her
Justice P.S. Dinesh Kumarpassed the order, questioning the criminal proceedings initiated against Faisal Khan in 2012. The court said,
The woman filed unbelievable and self-contradicting allegations. The allegations against Mr Khan are designed to harass him.
Though the complaint was filed alleging commission of offence by the petitioner [Mr. Khan], it is in fact he who has suffered untold misery at the hands of the complainant [Ms. Asma].
Triple Talaq
Woman’s Second Marriage With Khan
When Nazia married Khan in 2008, she was facing a petition, filed by her first husband in 2006, seeking restitution of conjugal rights, before a civil court, which had temporarily restrained her from remarrying
She had not disclosed this aspect to Khan, and her relationship with him came to an end in August 2011 after she refused to go with him to Kuwait, where he was employed
Her complaint of domestic violence filed in 2012 against Khan was dismissed with costs by a court in Mysore in 2016 as she was found to have married again, for the third time
Her plea filed in 2014 seeking maintenance from Khan was dismissed as she was found to have married earlier, the High Court noted, while pointing out that a court in Mysore in October 2018 had allowed a suit filed in 2015 by Khan and declared that his marriage with Nazia was “null and void”
So technically, Nazia wanted money from second husband with whom her marriage was illegal and she wanted the maintenance from him, despite having married for the third time
Incidentally, the government of India believes in making only one sided gender centric laws, which leave husbands with nearly zero scope to defend themselves. This verdict is extremely rare and often the courts only quash cases with no punishment whatsoever to women.
Join our Facebook Group or follow us on social media by clicking on the icons below
Donate to Voice For Men India
If you find value in our work, you may choose to donate to Voice For Men Foundation via Milaap OR via UPI: voiceformenindia@hdfcbank (80G tax exemption applicable)
Nasia Asma deserves Jail,
1. she married an NRI man 15yrs.
Higher then her age,
2. she didn’t join him to Kuwait, 3. got a girl child delivered,
4. filed fake case of Dowery
498a,
5. Made the man leave his job and
settle in India
6. Used men emotionally
7. Used Judiciary for her
benefits
8. Spilled Carrier & Reputation
of man
9. Gave mental pressure of court
case
And Nazia Asma is punished for just Rs.25,000/-
Nasia Asma has done all types of cruelty on Husband & Crime of misusing Judiciary.
झूठे और फेक मन घड़त केस करने वाली औरत, उसको सपोर्ट करने वाले रिश्तेदार, सही से जांच ना करने वाले पुलिसकर्मी और वकीलों पर सज़ा का प्रावधान होना चाहिए।
तभी इसी मक्कार औरतों से मर्द बच पाएंगे, मर्द वह प्रजाति है जिसे शुरू से रोने नहीं दिया जाता यह कह कर कि वो मर्द है, जबकि घर के बाहर के सब काम की ज़िम्मेदारी उस पर बचपन से लाद दी जाती है चाहे वह हरा धनिया लाना हो या अस्पताल स्कूल कॉलेज बैंक के काम, बहनों की ज़िम्मेदारी हो या मा बाप की या बीवी बच्चो की।
मर्द को भी दर्द होता है
मर्दों को भी जीने का बराबर हक और कानून दो
Nasia Asma deserves Jail,
1. she married an NRI man 15yrs.
Higher then her age,
2. she didn’t join him to Kuwait, 3. got a girl child delivered,
4. filed fake case of Dowery
498a,
5. Made the man leave his job and
settle in India
6. Used men emotionally
7. Used Judiciary for her
benefits
8. Spilled Carrier & Reputation
of man
9. Gave mental pressure of court
case
And Nazia Asma is punished for just Rs.25,000/-
Nasia Asma has done all types of cruelty on Husband & Crime of misusing Judiciary.
Nasia Asma Definitely deserves jail
No Men’s Respect & Life is not that cheap.
झूठे और फेक मन घड़त केस करने वाली औरत, उसको सपोर्ट करने वाले रिश्तेदार, सही से जांच ना करने वाले पुलिसकर्मी और वकीलों पर सज़ा का प्रावधान होना चाहिए।
तभी इसी मक्कार औरतों से मर्द बच पाएंगे, मर्द वह प्रजाति है जिसे शुरू से रोने नहीं दिया जाता यह कह कर कि वो मर्द है, जबकि घर के बाहर के सब काम की ज़िम्मेदारी उस पर बचपन से लाद दी जाती है चाहे वह हरा धनिया लाना हो या अस्पताल स्कूल कॉलेज बैंक के काम, बहनों की ज़िम्मेदारी हो या मा बाप की या बीवी बच्चो की।
मर्द को भी दर्द होता है
मर्दों को भी जीने का बराबर हक और कानून दो