• Home
  • About Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Share Your Story
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
Voice For Men
ads
  • HOME
  • IN THE NEWS
    • ALLEGED FALSE RAPE
    • 498A CASES
    • MURDER
    • SUICIDE
    • IMPACT ON CHILDREN
    • CRIME HAS NO GENDER
    • ADULTERY
    • ALIMONY
    • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
  • IN THE LAW
    • HIGH COURT
    • SUPREME COURT
    • OTHER COURTS
  • IN THE SOCIAL
    • GENDER STORIES
    • BLOGS
  • HIS STORY
    • SPEAK UP MEN
    • SUCCESS STORY
  • NON TIER-I CITIES
  • वौइस् फॉर मेंन हिंदी
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • IN THE NEWS
    • ALLEGED FALSE RAPE
    • 498A CASES
    • MURDER
    • SUICIDE
    • IMPACT ON CHILDREN
    • CRIME HAS NO GENDER
    • ADULTERY
    • ALIMONY
    • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
  • IN THE LAW
    • HIGH COURT
    • SUPREME COURT
    • OTHER COURTS
  • IN THE SOCIAL
    • GENDER STORIES
    • BLOGS
  • HIS STORY
    • SPEAK UP MEN
    • SUCCESS STORY
  • NON TIER-I CITIES
  • वौइस् फॉर मेंन हिंदी
No Result
View All Result
Voice For Men
No Result
View All Result
Home IN THE NEWS ALIMONY

Pay Up Maintenance To Earning Wives Even If You Don’t Earn Single Penny – High Court To Husbands

Team VFMI by Team VFMI
December 26, 2019
in ALIMONY, HIGH COURT, IN THE LAW, IN THE NEWS
1
mensdayout.com
Madhya Pradesh High Court order husband to pay maintenance under any circumstances (Representation Image Only)

Madhya Pradesh High Court order husband to pay maintenance under any circumstances (Representation Image Only)

857
SHARES
4.6k
VIEWS

Husband is obliged to give maintenance/alimony fixed by court to the wife, even if the man does not earn a single penny. Yes, this is what Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled in several cases, completely overlooking the facts in respective cases.

Justice JP Gupta, while commenting in one such case, said that if the husband is physically competent, then it is his obligation to provide sufficient maintenance to his wife and minor children even if he is not earning even a single penny. The husband will have to make every effort to raise the amount of maintenance.

If the husband is living separately due to family dispute or harassment by wife, it does not spare him from taking onus of the well-being of his wife and minor children.

ALSO READ –

Mohammed Shami’s US Visa Gets Rejected Due to Domestic Violence Case; BCCI Steps In

In many cases, harassed husbands who have been asked to cough up sums to fully abled wives, had approached the state High Court. However, the reduction in maintenance has been rejected by court…….because perhaps our judiciary believes that come what may, man is the provider for a woman. A tight slap to Gender Equality Warriors!

Case 1:

  • Har Prasad Sahu of Bhopal was fed up with daily harassment from his wife and decided to live separately after 12 years of marriage
  • Wife then filed a case for maintenance in the family court in April 2017
  • The court then instructed Sahu to pay Rs 7,000 per month as maintenance to his wife every month
  • Sahu appealed to the High Court seeking the reduction of the amount, which was rejected

Case 2:

  • A case of maintenance was filed by wife of Arvind Yadav – resident of Budhni, Sehore
  • In December 2017, the family court ordered Arvind to pay Rs 2500 as compensation to the wife and Rs 1500 to the child every month
  • Arvind appealed in the High Court pleading that his total income was only Rs 4,000 per month, and thus the amount of maintenance should be reduced
  • The High Court had dismissed his appeal as well

Case 3:

Justice Vishnu Pratap Singh Chauhan of the High Court has said that even if the husband is not able to produce proof of his source of income, but has sufficient income, he is bound to pay up the amount of maintenance fixed by the court to his estranged wife.

ALSO READ –

Does A Husband Have Fair Rights During A Divorce Petition In India?

Case 4:

  • Using another absurd logic, the High Court stated stated that the applicant husband has not anywhere proved that he is physically or mentally incapable of earning money
  • The applicant claims that he is earning wages and this means he can surely work well to provide for his family
  • On the other hand, if the husband argues that his wife too is earning, it clearly shows how husband wants to avoid his responsibility of taking care of his wife

Case 5:

  • Khandwa resident Pankaj Jadhav’s wife applied for maintenance in the Family Court
  • In December 2018, the court ordered the husband to Rs 4,000 per month to his wife
  • Pankaj filed an appeal by the High Court, arguing that his monthly income was only Rs 2,500-3,000 per month
  • He also claimed that his wife was herself running a beauty parlour from which she earned Rs 5,000 per month
  • The High Court dismissed the appeal and stayed the lower court order

The Supreme Court in 2015 issued a guideline regarding maintenance allowance in the case of Shamima Farooqui against Shahid Khan, stating that livelihood does not just mean survival. The Supreme Court ordered that the amount of maintenance should be fixed in a way that a wife can continue to live her life the way she would in her husband’s home.

voiceformenindia.com
Madhya Pradesh Family Court (Representation Image Only)

Our Take:

  • At the outset, our judicial system is extremely flawed, because against one judgement, you will come across several counter judgements by various courts
  • This is because the quantum, timelines and analysis of why a woman should be awarded maintenance/alimony solely rests on the understanding of the judges
  • Thus such highly subjective orders cannot become the basis of absolute justice
  • Why is monthly maintenance awarded even before looking at the facts of any case?
  • This is nothing but a huge extortion tool handed over to wives which encourages them to demand money even if they are guilty and in the wrong
  • Once the maintenance is fixed, women often stop coming to courts for arguments on main divorce petitions, because there is no timeline to end such cases
  • When Supreme Court says “women must enjoy same status as she would in her husband’s home”, there are no timelines taken into factor whatsoever
  • So if a couple had a particular lifestyle in the year 2001 and the case has been dragged until 2019, why should a separated wife be awarded maintenance on current income?
  • It is like awarding them a lifetime tax free allowance which they effectively use to keep dragging and filing additional cases back on the husband himself
  • On one hand, society and judiciary talks of gender justice and on other side, they still want to make only the man as sole provider of a home (even if the wife is earning)
  • Child maintenance must be a separate issue and both parents have to be equally responsible in raising the child
  • Until this system of easy money to separated wives is not curtailed, men will be the only sufferers – whether they stay with the woman or stay away from her due to her harassment

And if you are not already shocked by our highly biased system, read the case below where a disabled man was ordered by court to pay alimony to his wife who allegedly made his life miserable. The only option Shiv had was to crowdfund his alimony to get rid of the life long problem.

ALSO READ –

http://voiceformenindia.com/his-story/shiv-kumar-alimony-crowdfund-milaap/

Follow www.mensdayout.com on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram

Join our Facebook Group or follow us on social media by clicking on the icons below

Donate to Voice For Men India

If you find value in our work, you may choose to donate to Voice For Men Foundation via Milaap OR via UPI: voiceformenindia@hdfcbank (80G tax exemption applicable)

Donate Now (80G Eligible)

Follow Us

Tags: divorcein the lawInterim MaintenanceMadhya Pradesh High CourtmaintenanceNo Maintenance to Educated and Working Wives
Team VFMI

Team VFMI

Comments 1

  1. Jayesh says:
    5 years ago

    Our Judiciary proves to be “Andha kanoon”

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support Us To Spread The Cause
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
mensdayout.com

Husband Sends Wife To NZ On Study Visa By Paying Rs 21 Lakhs | Wife Blocks His Mobile After Reaching

October 2, 2019
mensdayout.com

Daughter Takes Mum On Her Honeymoon; Months Later Mother Is Pregnant With Son-In-Law

January 20, 2020
mensdayout.com

Mumbai Shocker | 16-Year-Old Porn Addict Girl Forces Younger Brother For Sex Against His Consent; Now Pregnant

August 28, 2021
mensdayout.com

Accountant Left 24-Page Suicide Note Alleging Harassment And Infidelity By Wife

23
mensdayout.com

ASCI Upholds Complaint | CARS24 Sexist Ad To Be Modified Or Withdrawn By June 17

16
mensdayout.com

“I Curse Myself For Getting My Son Married As Per Indian Laws”: Story Of A Senior Citizen Father

15
voiceformenindia.com

Bribery Charges By Rippling Co-Founder Prasanna Sankar Were Fabricated To Garner Public Sympathy: Chennai Police Report

April 26, 2025
voiceformenindia.com

READ ORDER | Supreme Court Quashes Rape On Promise Of Marriage Case; Calls It Abuse Of Process Of Law

April 25, 2025
voiceformenindia.com

READ ORDER | Delhi High Court Quashes Rape FIR After Accused Man Marries Complainant Live-in Partner

January 31, 2025

Follow Us

Recent News

voiceformenindia.com

Bribery Charges By Rippling Co-Founder Prasanna Sankar Were Fabricated To Garner Public Sympathy: Chennai Police Report

April 26, 2025
voiceformenindia.com

READ ORDER | Supreme Court Quashes Rape On Promise Of Marriage Case; Calls It Abuse Of Process Of Law

April 25, 2025
voiceformenindia.com

READ ORDER | Delhi High Court Quashes Rape FIR After Accused Man Marries Complainant Live-in Partner

January 31, 2025
voiceformenindia.com

‘Domestic Violence Against Men’ Delhi HC Order Underscores Principles Of Gender Neutral Justice: Men’s Rights NGO

January 27, 2025

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

    Subscribe to our mailing list to receive monthly updates in your inbox!

    Voice For Men

    Voice For Men India publishes articles about Men's Rights, Gender Biased Laws, Impact on Children of Separated Parents & His Story. Do check out the "Other Side.

    Follow Us

    Browse by Category

    • 498A CASES
    • ADULTERY
    • ALIMONY
    • ALLEGED FALSE RAPE
    • BLOGS
    • CRIME HAS NO GENDER
    • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
    • GENDER STORIES
    • HIGH COURT
    • HIS STORY
    • IMPACT ON CHILDREN
    • IN THE LAW
    • IN THE NEWS
    • IN THE SOCIAL
    • MURDER
    • NON TIER-I CITIES
    • OTHER COURTS
    • SPEAK UP MEN
    • SUCCESS STORY
    • SUICIDE
    • SUPREME COURT
    • Uncategorized

    Recent News

    voiceformenindia.com

    Bribery Charges By Rippling Co-Founder Prasanna Sankar Were Fabricated To Garner Public Sympathy: Chennai Police Report

    April 26, 2025
    voiceformenindia.com

    READ ORDER | Supreme Court Quashes Rape On Promise Of Marriage Case; Calls It Abuse Of Process Of Law

    April 25, 2025
    voiceformenindia.com

    READ ORDER | Delhi High Court Quashes Rape FIR After Accused Man Marries Complainant Live-in Partner

    January 31, 2025
    voiceformenindia.com

    ‘Domestic Violence Against Men’ Delhi HC Order Underscores Principles Of Gender Neutral Justice: Men’s Rights NGO

    January 27, 2025
    voiceformenindia.com

    READ JUDGMENT | Delhi High Court Calls For Gender Neutrality In Domestic Violence Cases | Voice For Men India

    January 24, 2025
    voiceformenindia.com

    READ JUDGMENT | Can Mother Be Accused Of Abetting Son’s Girlfriend’s Suicide If She Asked Her “To Die”: Supreme Court Responds

    January 23, 2025
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Share Your Story
    • Advertise With Us
    • Contact Us

    © 2019 Voice For Men India

    No Result
    View All Result
    • HOME
    • IN THE NEWS
      • ALLEGED FALSE RAPE
      • 498A CASES
      • MURDER
      • SUICIDE
      • IMPACT ON CHILDREN
      • CRIME HAS NO GENDER
      • ADULTERY
      • ALIMONY
      • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
    • IN THE LAW
      • HIGH COURT
      • SUPREME COURT
      • OTHER COURTS
    • IN THE SOCIAL
      • GENDER STORIES
      • BLOGS
    • HIS STORY
      • SPEAK UP MEN
      • SUCCESS STORY
    • NON TIER-I CITIES
    • वौइस् फॉर मेंन हिंदी

    © 2019 Voice For Men India